Globally, the pet meals business has by no means been bigger and extra worthwhile. Due to this, cat homeowners in 2023 are confronted with selecting between an ever-expanding number of diets for his or her feline buddies. That will help you out, we’ve written this in-depth comparability of two family-owned cat meals manufacturers which will attraction to an analogous group of kitty homeowners. Preserve studying for our ideas and evaluation of Open Farm vs. Fromm cat meals.
A Sneak Peek on the Winner: Fromm Cat Meals
We picked Fromm cat meals as our successful model based mostly on its availability and attraction to a wider vary of cat homeowners. Total, Fromm can also be the extra reasonably priced choice. Two recipes we particularly like from Fromm are:
About Open Farm Cat Meals
Who Makes Open Farm Cat Meals?
Open Farm cat meals is produced by Open Farm, which is a small, family-owned firm based mostly in Canada. Recipes are developed in Canada and manufactured at a Minnesota facility. The corporate was based in 2014.
What Merchandise Does Open Farm Supply for Cats?
Open Farm produces conventional dry and moist meals in a number of protein selections. In addition they produce freeze-dried uncooked diets, together with broth and different meals toppers. Whereas they provide a dry weight loss program formulated for kittens, there are not any different specialised weight loss program choices, equivalent to senior formulations or mild meals.
The place Is Open Farm Cat Meals Bought?
Open Farm is obtainable for buy on-line, with the choice for one-time purchases or auto cargo on a schedule of your alternative. It may also be bought at specialty pet shops in varied areas, with extra obtainable on a regular basis. The Open Farm web site gives a useful retailer locator however recommends you name the retailers first to make sure they’ve inventory obtainable.
What Is Open Farm Cat Meals Recognized For?
Open Farm is understood for its concentrate on the transparency and traceability of its substances. On the web site, yow will discover sourcing data for each ingredient in its meals. They prioritize utilizing native substances from humane farms, which is why their pet meals plant is positioned in Minnesota, within the coronary heart of the farm nation. The corporate can also be dedicated to sustainability and sustaining a low carbon footprint.
Professionals
A number of high-protein dry and moist meals recipes can be found
Made by a small, family-owned firm
Makes use of high-quality, traceable substances
Clear about ingredient sourcing
Sustainability and humane remedy of animals are a precedence
Cons
Not broadly obtainable in retail shops
No senior or mild meals can be found
About Fromm Cat Meals
Who Makes Fromm Cat Meals?
Fromm cat meals is made by Fromm Household Meals, a Wisconsin-based, family-owned, and operated firm. It’s manufactured at three company-owned crops positioned in Wisconsin. Fromm has been producing pet meals since 1949.
What Merchandise Does Fromm Supply for Cats?
Fromm produces dry and moist cat meals, in addition to treats. They produce grownup, senior, kitten, and weight management recipes. Complete-grain and grain-free formulation are each obtainable.
The place Is Fromm Cat Meals Bought?
Fromm merchandise, together with cat meals, are bought in specialty pet shops throughout the US and Canada. They’re additionally obtainable from restricted retailers in Hong Kong, Macau, Singapore, the UK, and the Czech Republic. Fromm Cat Meals may also be bought from varied on-line retail companions. Fromm continues to develop the provision of their merchandise in native pet shops.
What Is Fromm Cat Meals Recognized For?
Fromm Cat Meals is understood for its tight high quality management and meals security procedures. All merchandise are manufactured at company-owned crops, permitting Fromm to supervise and monitor all areas of the manufacturing course of. They conduct security testing on substances and third get together testing of completed merchandise. They’re additionally recognized for prioritizing the standard of pet meals over producing massive portions at a time. Small batches of meals are produced by well-trained workers, with constant high quality because the aim.
Professionals
A number of recipes can be found, together with senior, kitten, and weight management diets
High quality management is an organization precedence
Produced in company-owned crops
Grain-free and whole-grain diets can be found
Accessible in specialty pet shops or on-line
Cons
Much less transparency about ingredient sourcing
Solely obtainable from small pet shops or on-line, no large retailer chains
3 Most Common Open Farm Pet Meals Recipes
1. Homestead Turkey and Rooster Dry Cat Meals
*Use code EXCITEDCATS20 and save in your first auto-ship order.
Homestead Turkey and Chicken Dry Cat Food is a high-protein, calorie-dense providing from Open Farm. It’s made with turkey, hen, and a mix of fish meal proteins, and it additionally comprises fruits, greens, and coconut oil for added dietary profit. It additionally options prebiotic fiber for digestive well being. All ingredient sources are documented on Open Farm’s web site, and the meat comes from humane-certified farms. As a result of it comprises hen and fish, frequent allergen triggers, this weight loss program isn’t the most effective choose for cats with meals sensitivities. It is just obtainable in 4 or 8-pound baggage, with no bulk choice.
Professionals
Excessive protein weight loss program
Accommodates prebiotic fiber
Humane-certified, simply traceable substances
Cons
Not a great choice for cats with meals sensitivities
The most important obtainable bag is simply 8 kilos
2. Harvest Rooster Rustic Mix Moist Cat Meals
*Use code EXCITEDCATS20 and save in your first auto-ship order.
Harvest Chicken Rustic Blend wet cat food options humanely raised hen blended with bone broth and greens to make a clean, high-protein combination. Serve this meals by itself or blended into dry kibble. Harvest Rooster Rustic Mix comprises fatty acids and is free from synthetic colours, flavors, and preservatives. Like all Open Farm diets, you may verify the supply of all substances on this meals on its web site. This moist meals is simply obtainable in 5.5 oz cartons and a case of 12, so it’s not essentially the most cost-effective for those who’re utilizing it as the first weight loss program.
Professionals
Excessive in protein
Comprised of humanely raised hen
No synthetic colours, flavors, or preservatives
Cons
Solely obtainable in a single measurement
Not essentially the most cost-effective choice
3. Kitten Grain-Free Dry Cat Meals
Picture Credit score: Open Farm
*Use code EXCITEDCATS20 and save in your first auto-ship order.
Open Farm’s Grain-Free Kitten Food is made with a mix of poultry and fish sources, forming a weight loss program with elevated fats and protein ranges to assist rising cats. The substances are all sustainably sourced from humane farms, with no GMOs, hormones, or antibiotics. This kitten weight loss program comprises added vitamins like prebiotics, fiber, Vitamin A, and taurine. Kittens are much less more likely to endure from meals allergic reactions, however you need to be conscious that hen and fish are two of the most common allergy triggers in cats.
Professionals
Elevated protein and fats ranges to assist wholesome progress
No substances with GMOs, hormones, or antibiotics
Accommodates added fiber, prebiotics, taurine, and Vitamin A
Cons
Not your best option for kittens with early meals sensitivities
3 Most Common Fromm Cat Meals Recipes
1. Fromm Grownup Gold Cat Meals
Fromm Adult Gold Cat Food is a chicken-based weight loss program formulated to satisfy the wants of wholesome grownup kitties. It comprises entire grains, probiotics, antioxidants, and fatty acids for coat well being. You’ll additionally discover collagen for joint well being. Fromm Grownup Gold comprises 32% protein and 18% fats. It’s obtainable in 4-pound and 10-pound baggage. Cats with potential meals allergic reactions could not do properly with this weight loss program. It additionally consists of cheese as one of many substances, and a few cats don’t tolerate dairy merchandise properly.
Professionals
Made with entire grains and a mix of proteins
Contains vitamins to assist digestive, immune, coat, and joint well being
Accessible in a bigger, 10-pound bag
Cons
Not your best option for cats with meals sensitivities
Some cats don’t tolerate dairy merchandise (cheese) properly
2. Fromm Shredded Turkey in Gravy Entrée
This canned diet is formulated for all life phases from kitten to senior. It’s made with turkey and candy potatoes with loads of moisture from broth, and it gives protein and moisture to maintain your kitty well-hydrated. Fromm Shredded Turkey in Gravy comprises 9% protein and just one.5% fats. With solely 99 energy per can, you’ll doubtless have to feed fairly a bit to satisfy your cat’s day by day calorie wants, which might get costly. This meals may go higher as a complement to a extra nutrient-dense dry weight loss program. Cats that favor a pate-style canned weight loss program could not like the feel of this meals.
Professionals
Excessive in protein and low in fats
Elevated moisture for hydration
Formulated for all life phases
Cons
Not very nutrient-dense
Not all cats will like the feel
3. Fromm Kitten Gold Dry Meals
Fromm Kitten Gold Dry Food comprises a number of protein sources—hen, duck, and salmon meal—and is formulated for kittens, pregnant felines, and nursing cats. It comprises 34% protein and 20% fats. In comparison with different kitten diets (together with Open Farm,) Fromm Kitten Gold has a decrease protein content material. This recipe comprises fatty acids to assist correct mind improvement in kittens. You’ll additionally discover probiotics and antioxidants for digestive and immune support. Cats with meals sensitivities could not do properly with this weight loss program as a result of it comprises hen and fish. This meals is obtainable in 4 or 10-pound baggage.
Professionals
Formulated for kittens or pregnant and nursing cats
Accommodates fatty acids, antioxidants, and probiotics
Accessible in 10-pound baggage
Cons
Not as excessive in protein as other kitten diets
Not a sensible choice for cats with meals sensitivities
Recall Historical past of Open Farm and Fromm Pet Meals
Fromm Cat Meals has by no means been recalled, based mostly on our analysis. Nevertheless, the corporate has issued two separate recollects for canned pet food, as soon as in 2016 and once more in 2021. Each recollects had been resulting from abnormally excessive ranges of Vitamin D within the meals. In every case, the issue was found based mostly on in-house testing.
Open Farm has not introduced recollects on any merchandise as of the time of this writing.
Picture Credit score: Patrik Slezak, Shutterstock
Open Farm vs. Fromm Comparability
Style
Based mostly on person critiques, most cats appear to benefit from the style of Open Farm and Fromm merchandise general. In fact, cats being cats, there are at all times some who would be the exception to this rule. We’ll give Open Farm the sting on style right here as a result of extra person critiques talked about it being one of many solely meals their choosy cats will eat constantly.
Dietary Worth
Each Fromm and Open Farm cat meals merchandise are formulated to satisfy the requirements set by the Affiliation of American Feed Management Officers (AAFCO), as all business pet diets bought in the US should. This implies they meet the identical fundamental vitamin requirements. Neither firm performs feeding trials or nutritional studies on their cat food, based mostly on the data we uncovered throughout our analysis.
Based mostly on the obtainable data now we have, we’ll give Open Farm the sting on dietary worth as a result of they’re extra clear about the place they get their substances, giving extra confidence that they supply the meant dietary worth. In addition they state on their web site that their diets are formulated by an animal nutritionist.
Picture Credit score: Lita Keire, Shutterstock
Value
A few of Fromm’s higher-end diets are comparable in value to Open Farm, however general they get the sting on value. Fromm cat meals presents extra choices which are decrease in value than Open Farm, in each canned and dry formulation. In addition they provide dry meals in bigger baggage than Open Farm, which is cheaper, particularly for multi-cat households.
Choice
Once more, Fromm wins this class hands-down. They merely provide extra merchandise, extra recipes, and extra specialised formulation than Open Farm. Grain-inclusive, grain-free, normal and connoisseur recipes, weight management diets, plus a number of protein selections can all be bought from Fromm. In addition they produce cat treats, which Open Farm doesn’t presently.
On the planet of pet meals, Open Farm continues to be comparatively new, having been based in 2014. Fromm Household Meals, then again, has been making pet meals for the reason that mid-Twentieth century. We count on Open Farm will proceed to develop its product choice over time, however for now, Fromm will get the sting right here.
Picture Credit score: Pixel-Shot, Shutterstock
Total
Total, we selected Fromm Cat Meals as our winner. Whereas we just like the transparency Open Farm brings to its ingredient sourcing and admire its dedication to sustainability, we felt that Fromm provided essentially the most attraction and worth to a broader vary of cat homeowners. It’s extra broadly obtainable on the market each on-line and in retail shops, is cheaper, and presents a wider vary of merchandise. Whereas they don’t make it as straightforward to search out out the place all their substances come from as Open Farm, Fromm does worth strict high quality management and produces meals out of company-owned crops.
Conclusion
Fromm Cat Meals wins our head-to-head comparability of kitty diets based mostly on its broader vary of merchandise, bag sizes, and availability. We really feel that this firm’s merchandise attraction to a wider number of cat homeowners than Open Farm. Nevertheless, Open Farm is the superior alternative for the buyer who’s prepared to spend somewhat extra to assist an organization with values that match their very own. Open Farm’s dedication to sustainability, use of humanely raised meat, and transparency in ingredient sourcing make their meals an ideal match for a lot of cat homeowners.
